But I didn’t feel like cherishing it with my teammates for some reason.

I’d much rather have a repeat of my night with Courtney instead. Even though we didn’t have sex, and I didn’t even try to cross that line with her.

Maybe I do need to go to student health …

“Good job out there today, Kyle.” Coach Whitten stepped behind me. “You more than deserved the game ball.”

“You still haven’t given it to me, Coach.”

“I will after you tell me the truth about what you turned in this morning,” he said. “Who wrote your latest essay about The Vagina Monologues?”

“I did,” I said. “It was very thought-provoking wasn’t it?”

“A little too thought-provoking.” He crossed his arms. “I ran it through a plagiarism checker and I couldn’t find anything.”

“Because all of the words are original.” I smiled at the thought of Courtney retooling it over the phone last night. “I enjoyed the show this time around.”

“Sure, you did,” he said. “You can consider the punishment lifted, but if I hear a word about you being reckless tonight, you’ll be watching that show for the rest of the season.”

His words were enough for me to give Trevor my credit card in lieu of joining the team at South Side.

Walking over to Grayson’s locker, I cleared my throat.

“What do you say to you and me hanging out tonight?” I asked. “We can go to some place on Carnegie Mellon’s campus, so we can catch up in private.”

“I can’t,” he said. “I promised Charlotte Taylor that I would meet her at an art gallery. Then we’re going back to the apartment to watch a movie.”

“I’m sorry, who did you just say?”

“Charlotte Taylor.” He smiled. “You heard me.”

I blinked.

Charlotte Taylor was the type of girl that would make a guy go out with her ten times before giving him her phone number. I’d heard countless tales about how she invited guys up to her room for hours-long discussions about books. And coffee.

“Is there something in your eye, Kyle?”

“What’s left of my best friend’s dignity.” I crossed my arms. “Are you aware that you can get any other girl—literally any other girl, on this campus?”

He smiled, but he didn’t answer.

“Are you also aware that the woman you’re about to spend time on is probably a virgin, and she probably wants to remain that way for the rest of her life?”

“Kyle, Charlotte’s sex life is none of your business.”

“It’s none of yours either, since I can guarantee that you’ll never have any with her.”

He laughed. “Everything isn’t about sex.”

“So, you’re hanging out with her willingly?”

“Yes, Kyle.” He laughed. “Willingly.”

“Why?”

“Because I like her a lot,” he said. “I know you have no idea what that feels like, but one girl is more than enough sometimes. Then again, since you’re probably up to twenty or thirty by now, I know that seems unfathomable.”

“You know, I’ve been meaning to talk to you about my number for a while …” I let out a sigh. “I am setting an all-new record this year—without even trying. I never even knew this number was possible.”

“Congratulations.” He patted my shoulder, not catching my drift at all. “Feel free to spare me the details. I don’t think I can handle them right now.”

I considered telling him anyway, but something told me to hold back.

“Enjoy your night with the Virgin Mary, then.” I stepped back. “I’ll see you whenever you get home.”

“You’re not going out at all?”

“No, I uh—” I remembered I had a few questions from Courtney to answer. “My room will suffice for the night.”

Courtney: Then

Senior Year

Pittsburgh

I scooped Julia into my arms Saturday night and stormed out of my apartment.

I’d begged Judy-April not to leave tulips out in the kitchen since they could literally kill my cat, and I’d come home to find three huge bouquets of them on our coffee table. Right next to where Julia liked to play.

I can’t take this shit anymore.

I made it halfway to Panther Central before realizing that they would probably set up an emergency counseling session between us. They’d probably tell me that I was in the wrong for having a kitten in university housing anyway.

Pulling out my phone, I called Kyle.

“Yeah, Court?” He answered on the first ring.

“Can I come over to your place and stay the night?”

The line went silent.

“Hello?” I asked. “Kyle?”

“What did you just ask me?”

“I said, can I come over?” I let out a sigh. “My roommate is—It’s a long story. Please.”

“Of course, you can come over.”

“Can I bring my friend to stay the night, too?”

“You’re sending me some very mixed signals right now,” he said. “I just got out of the shower—where I spent the entire time thinking about you, so I need you to tone it down.”

I held back a laugh. “I’m five minutes away. I’ll be wearing shades and in all black.”

“Why do I need to know that?”

I hung up without giving him an explanation.

A few minutes later, I stepped onto the walkway at Bouquet Gardens.

Kyle was standing next to his front door to let me in, but I motioned for him to meet me on the side of the building—right next to his bedroom window.

I looked over my shoulder to make sure that no one else was around, and then I tapped on the glass.

Laughing, Kyle pushed the window open and pulled me inside.

I flopped onto his bed, amazed at how clean his room was. With the exception of the tower of empty liquor bottles in the corner, everything was immaculate.

“Is there any reason why you can’t use the front door like a normal person?” he asked.

“Yeah,” I said. “The girls who live above you run a blog called The Skanks of Pitt. They keep track of all the girls you and your teammates have in and out of this building.”

“Since when?”

“Since forever,” I said. “They take pictures of the walk of shame and include short stories about how they think the night went.”

“Interesting.” He smiled. “I had no idea. Where’s your friend?”

I opened my bag and Julia stepped out.

Unimpressed with her surroundings, she returned to the bag and curled into a ball.

“Hmmm.” He walked over to his mini-fridge and pulled out a water bottle. Then he poured it into a small bowl and set it onto the floor.

“Why does it look like you’re about to cry, Court?” he asked.

“Because my roommate is literally the devil, and I hate her.” My voice cracked. “I didn’t do anything to her—ever, and she treats me and Julia like trash for no reason. I just want to sleep it off.”