I was doing okay. Instead of drowning in a land of depression, I decided that picking up a library card would be a better choice. Drowning myself in make-believe seemed more promising. I traveled to the library every afternoon, walking in the warm sun right after school and returning home when the moon was high.

One morning before school, Hailey was brushing out her hair and she sat her brush down. “Theo asked me out again.”

I turned to her, disgusted for her. She hadn’t spoken about him in the weeks since the party. “What an ass**le,” I muttered.

“Yeah.” She paused. “I’m thinking about saying yes.”

My eyes widened. “You’re kidding?”

She wasn’t. I watched her head fall to the ground and her shoulders slump. “I’m not like you, okay? I don’t have guys throwing themselves at me—let alone looking at me. Theo’s my only shot at a relationship.”

“The people ‘throwing’ themselves at me are total dicks. Trust me. You don’t want that. Plus, you’re seventeen, not eighty-three. There will be other guys.”

She paused, rolling my comment through her brain. I sighed when I watched her shake her head. “He apologized. For what he did with Lia.”

“You can apologize for punching someone, but it doesn’t stop the bruising.”

“Did you read that from one of your books?” she snickered.

“Hailey…”

She pulled out a small bag with pills in it. “He wants me to try these. He said if we have something in common, then we might work out better.”

I stared at her as if she had lost her damn mind. “He wants you to take drugs to be closer to him?”

“Are you a virgin?”

I rubbed my fingers against my temple and shook my head. Her question had come out of left field. It was hardly after six a.m. and we were talking about drugs and sex. I definitely needed a cup of tea.

“No. My last boyfriend used me until he found something new.” I paused and thought about Billy and how he’d made me cry.

“Were you scared?” she whispered.

Terrified.

“I was sixteen. When I was younger, I was pretty stupid. Not in an over-the-top way, but in the normal ‘I’m a kid and don’t know anything about life’ type way. I slept with Billy, thinking that meant he loved me. It was scary, painful, and not in the least romantic. So we did it again and again. I hoped I would grow to like it because I loved him…

“Then, I found out he was doing the same thing with Susie Kenner. My sister Gabby would sit next to me in my bed, playing her guitar while I cried, telling me that Billy was a monstrous prick who probably had a small penis. She was right about his small penis. It was pretty nonexistent.”

Hailey laughed lightly. “Then what happened?”

“Billy called me afterwards, telling me that he missed me a lot and that he was interested in working out our problems, but I couldn’t even stop crying through his phone call. I told him I loved him, and he said he liked me well enough to make it work. All I would have to do was let him touch my br**sts every now and then and have sex whenever his parents weren’t around. My sister told me that I shouldn’t go back to him, because he really didn’t like me, but he was more interested in the size of my chest than the size of my brain. And Gabby promised me that the size of my brain was worth being interested in.”

The room filled with silence as I stared down at the carpeted floor. “Hailey, the size of your brain is worth being interested in.”

Her sigh was almost soundless. “She sounded like a great person, your sister.”

“The best,” I softly spoke. “Just think about it, all right? With Theo?”

She promised she would. But I saw the look of hope in her eyes when she spoke about him. I had the same hope when I went back to Billy, thinking it would be different. It wasn’t. Mom used to say, “Leave the past behind you so the future can find you.” That was my favorite saying of hers. After Henry cheated on her, she’d struggled to leave her past behind. But she finally had when she found Jeremy.

“How many more things on your bucket list have you checked off?” Hailey asked, changing the subject.

I blinked. “Just two.” And in an instant, Daniel’s lips were running across my mind. Kiss a stranger. I blinked again, erasing his memory.

Hailey held her hand out to me. “Let me see the note.”

Moving to my dresser, I picked up the letter and laid it in her hands. She opened it up and read it. “Hmm…” she said to herself, darting her eyes. “Number fourteen has already been checked off. ”

“What is it?” I asked, feeling myself growing a little eager.

“Make a new friend.” She smiled.

“You’re my friend?” I asked quietly, not knowing exactly what to say.

Hailey laughed. “Well, if I’m not, then this is very awkward.” She nodded once. “Of course I’m your friend. The way you stood up for me a few weeks ago… The way you still hate Theo… I think that’s friendship.” I smiled wide and she bumped me in the shoulder. “Where’s this note?!”

I moved over to the treasure box and quickly thumbed through the envelopes. Upon finding the letter, I read the front and sighed. It said in Gabby’s handwriting that this letter wasn’t for me—it was for the new friend. How had I not noticed that before? I ran my hands through the other letters, and lo and behold, they weren’t all addressed to me. My heart and lips frowned together.